The Biggest Conflicting Stories in the Terence Crutcher Shooting

Attorneys for both sides in the Terence Crutcher case have presented conflicting accounts of what happened on the night of Sept. 16.

Not Available Lead
Complex Original

Image via Complex Original

Not Available Lead

Last Friday, Tulsa Police Officer Betty Shelby fatally shot Terence Crutcher, a 40-year-old unarmed black man and father of four, after responding to a call about an abandoned car.

Tulsa Police released video and audio recordings of the Crutcher shooting on Monday, but much remains unknown. And attorneys for both Shelby and the Crutcher family have shared conflicting accounts about what happened on the night of Sept. 16, CNN reports.

1. High vs. sober

Shelby’s attorney Scott Wood told Tulsa World that Shelby had recently “completed drug-recognition expert training, [and] believed that Crutcher was acting like a person who might be under the influence of PCP.”

On Tuesday, Tulsa Police Sargeant and lead homicide detective David Walker confirmed that police discovered PCP in Crutcher’s SUV. But having PCP in your car isn’t the same thing as having it in your system—a crucial distinction to make when Shelby’s defense hinges on the claim that Crutcher was “under the influence.” Authorities have not said whether or not there was PCP in Crutcher’s system, but both attorneys have reacted to the possibility that he was intoxicated.

“He had a very hollow look in his face, kind of a thousand-yard stare, so to speak, and would not communicate, she could tell, he was not normal.” - Scott Wood, attorney representing Tulsa Police Officer Betty Shelby
If you are high on drugs, mentally ill, or not immediately compliant with police, you still don't deserve to die. https://t.co/DvhxSyyAAd

2. Window open vs. closed

One reason Shelby is said to have fired at Crutcher was that he started reaching into his vehicle, presumably for a weapon. But the question of whether or not Crutcher’s driver-side window was open remains to be answered. Video footage doesn’t offer any angles that definitively confirm or refute this, and both attorneys are steadfast in their conflicting accounts:

“She was yelling at him to stop, for probably at least 10 to 15 seconds, he gets to the window of the SUV, and has his hands in the air, looks at them, the side of the car at Officer Shelby, and his left hand goes into the window. Officer Turnbough also saw it, both of them reacted simultaneously; Turnbough firing his Taser, Betty Shelby firing one from her service weapon.” - Scott Wood, attorney representing Tulsa Police Officer Betty Shelby​

3. Armed vs. unarmed

Even if Crutcher’s driver-side window was open, Shelby’s fear that he was reaching for a weapon were unfounded. Tulsa Police Chief Chuck Jordan said Monday that no gun was found in Crutcher’s vehicle.

“That is true, but based on her experience and training, this person posed an immediate threat of harm to him or to her, and anyone present, and she thought if she didn’t take action right then everyone would be in peril of serious bodily harm or death.” - Scott Wood, attorney representing Tulsa Police Officer Betty Shelby​

On Tuesday, Crutcher's death was followed by the fatal police shooting of Keith Lamont Scott, a 43-year-old black man in North Carolina, which prompted protests in Charlotte. Both cases have reignited the nation’s ongoing discussion of racism and police brutality.

Keith Lamont Scott. Terence Crutcher. Too many others. This has got to end. -H

Federal, state, and local authorities have launched investigations into the officer-involved shooting, ​and Crutcher's twin sister Tiffany Crutcher has urged prosecutors to immediately press charges against Shelby.

Latest in Life