What Does Frank Ocean Owe His Fans?

Buzz around 'Boys Don't Cry' highlights unfair expectations of political work from black artists.

Not Available Lead
Complex Original

Image via Complex Original

Not Available Lead

Frank Ocean set himself up when he announced an album release date he could not live up to.

It had already been years since Ocean first amassed a fanbase after his career-launching mixtape and Grammy-award winning album. To his credit, he's one of the few men with music rooted in the rhythm and blues tradition who sings about love tenderly, feelings honestly, and desire earnestly—a stark contrast from his contemporaries who write songs for dance and escape, but don't necessarily offer much in the way of emotional intelligence. Ocean, by and large, was part of a trinity: him, Miguel, and The Weeknd, who were pushing the genre forward sonically but lyrically helping it return to a time when men had something to say besides, "I secretly wish I were a rapper." But the other members of said trinity have released new music since their breakout work—Ocean is the only one seemingly dragging his feet with that new-new.

Ocean could have easily been like Sade and effectively release new music whenever he felt compelled to, but he didn’t. Instead, he announced not only a new album, but a release date and some sort of publication to go with it. Revelations such as those only stoke the fire of anticipation. Simply skipping out on those obligations doesn’t make fans any less anxious. If anything, it ups the ante on Ocean to deliver music to satisfy their needs.

via GIPHY

Still, when it comes to what artists owe their fans, I don't think Frank Ocean owes us anything besides his best. But when you maintain dual identities—Black and artist—there are typically additional expectations assigned to you.

Ocean is a Black man, and in the year he’s taken to release his anticipated sophomore effort, Boys Don’t Cry, a lot has happened to America's socio-political landscape, prompting some to wonder whether or not these issues will be tackled on the album. 

Yet, that question feels more like projection. Has Frank Ocean really given us any reason to believe he would dive deeply into racial unrest and other political issues of the day? Granted, he has written Tumblr posts about Donald Trump and homophobia related to the Orlando shooting at Pulse nightclub, but 1) that’s Tumblr, and 2) there's no indication that’ll be reflected in his music. That expectation speaks to one that Black artists of every medium face: that we are to engage in the Black body, our Black bodies, as political all the time.

That we, as Black people in a world that so often shows value in Black culture but disdain for actual Black people, must speak on whatever injustice or oppression is happening.

That expectation speaks to one that Black artists of every medium face: that we are to engage in the Black body, our Black bodies, as political all the time.

Just this morning, I was tweeted about an article I wrote largely in jest, “Don’t you have something more important to write on?” My writing ranges from the serious to the very-much-less-than in subject matter, but make no mistake: I owe nobody anything but what I give them. The same applies to Frank Ocean and every other Black artist.

While it's helpful when a Black artist uses their platform to address inequality, that can happen a variety of ways. They're not beholden to addressing injustice in their work. Frankly, some artists are simply not equipped to do so, and often end up doing more harm than good. Years ago, Trey Songz told GQ, “I could make a hundred 'Bottoms Up's,’ but they won't change nobody's life.” He said he aspired to one-day follow the lead of soul singers like Marvin Gaye. However, when asked when might he plan to get “radical,” Trey answered, “I might. Give me a couple of years, though.”

I don’t know if Trey will ever get there, but I do know I don’t like the idea of dictating what an artist owes their fans. There are some artists who convey a certain of level of social consciousness and political knowledge in their work, which makes the expectation to hear more of that in the future more realistic. For those artists who don’t, they might grow into it, or they might not. However that goes, it should be organic and genuine. I’m not a fan of projecting my wants and needs onto any act.

Sometimes, their art offers the escapism many of us need, like taking us out of the dark world of the news cycle. As corny adult-contemporary '90s ballad as it may sound, sometimes love is just enough. Frank Ocean largely sings about every facet of love. I expect nothing more than him to continue to build on that. If something else comes, I will embrace it—but it is not owed to me.

There are certain things I’d like to hear from him, but it’s just a want. If nothing else, as a sincere fan of his work, I want Frank Ocean to simply be and create. He’s a singer; he owes us nothing but to sing a damn song. 

In the future, though, I do hope that whatever he decides to share with the world arrives on the date he promises.

Latest in Life